All Day

← All patterns

POSTED

Allocated labour

A system decides what you will do, and people comply — sometimes willingly.

The external half of the allocation problem. A mechanism — a computer, a lottery, a caste — hands out the work, and the society functions. Nobody is deceived about the fact of assignment; the argument is over whether being assigned is compatible with being free.

Le Guin wrote the hardest version. Anarres is an anarchist society with no property, no law and no compulsion, and it still runs a Division of Labour that posts people to jobs. Nothing forces you to accept. Almost everyone accepts, and the novel is unsparing about what happens to the one who does not — how a society without punishment nonetheless finds ways to make refusal unbearable.

This pattern is the one most likely to describe a real post-automation society, because allocation is what institutions do when work stops being economically necessary but socially remains so. Look at the mechanism in each case, and ask what would happen if you said no.


5 works give this answer